Gartner Survey Shows 40 Per Cent of SOA Users Don't Measure Time to Achieve Return on Investment
Gartner Survey Shows 40 Per Cent of SOA Users Don't Measure Time to Achieve Return on Investment
Analysts Explain How to Drive Value from SOA at Gartner SOA & Application Development and Integration Summit 2009, June 24-25 in London“Many companies come to SOA with excessive expectations, such as immediately achieving quicker project cycles, but users often are not aware of the efforts, resources and time needed to achieve these benefits,” said Massimo Pezzini, research vice president and fellow at Gartner. “Consequently, some SOA projects are perceived to have failed when in fact there are simply no well established metrics to evaluate success. Therefore sometimes the benefits are there, but people keep arguing how much better things are, and whether any improvement is really linked to SOA.”
“Under the pressure of technology vendors and with a generally too optimistic view of the possible benefits, organisations tend to over-spend on technology but under-spend from an organisational and governance viewpoint, so they come to the conclusion that SOA is expensive and doesn’t deliver,” said Paolo Malinverno, research vice president at Gartner.
To ensure expectations are realistic and accurate measurement towards goals takes place, Gartner recommends organisations initially focus on achieving just one key benefit from the list of potential business advantages of SOA. As the SOA effort matures, and the benefit starts being delivered, they should add further benefits and change or add to the measures accordingly. Choice of benefit depends on what is the most urgent or important business value that benefit can deliver, and how quickly it can be reached. The benefits include:
Improved Efficiency in Business Processes Execution -
Isolating the business logic from the functional application work
enables a clearer view of what a process is, and the rules to which it
adheres. This can be measured by lower process administrative costs,
higher visibility on existing/running business processes, and reduced
number of manual, paper-based steps; better service-level
effectiveness; quicker implementation of process iterative or of
variants of the same process for different contexts.
Quicker Time to Market/Shorter Project Cycles - The SOA
principle of modularity results in services than can be reused
repeatedly from different contexts. This can be measured by easier
internationalisation of processes and quicker adaptation of processes
to several products; the number of new products per unit of time; a
higher percentage of on-time delivery of products; shorter IT
integration of merging entities; a higher market coverage index (the
number of countries an organisation sells in, weighted by size of
revenue/target market global industry revenue); shortened project
delivery times; and number of projects completed per unit of time.
Enablement of New Fast-Growth Business Models – Again, SOA’s
modular, clearly defined, and shareable system interfaces, coupled with
better application quality delivered faster, enable system scalability
that can lead to new business models, such as e-commerce and cloud
computing. Typical measures are the number of new processes identified
and improved over 12 months; new ways/channels for interacting with
customers/suppliers, and traffic/number of transactions associated;
shortened time of integration of business partners; number of qualified
sales leads; decreasing cost of sales.
Shift in IT Culture From New Developments to Reuse - Services
being reused can be developed internally and outside the business (e.g.
for B2B document exchange, or to extract CRM data), and used on demand
on a SaaS basis. Measures can include SOA's total reuse factor (the
number of service consumers/number of services) is increasing; a
decreasing number of new service requests to the SOA centre of
excellence; a decreasing number of new services added to the repository
per month; and an increasing percentage of programmers' incentives
based on the number of services they reuse or on the number of
effectively reused services they design (not on the amount of software
they develop from scratch or maintain).
Lowering Total Cost of Application Development and Maintenance-
This cost tends to increase year by year, except when disruptive events
(such as a major cost-cutting initiatives) bring it down drastically,
causing significant pain within the organisation. A successful and
well-governed SOA project brings these costs down, with considerably
less organisational disruption. This cost is already measured in every
IT department, straight out of IT budget data. Another measure is the
reduced number of staff doing application development and maintenance,
or the higher productivity of existing staff, such as application
development or maintenance.
“Organisations must measure and communicate the success
of SOA projects continuously in terms of the positive business outcomes
achieved or the negative business outcomes avoided. If no-one knows
what SOA is good for, it will be seen as just another fashion wave, and
the SOA project will be at risk,” said Mr Pezzini.
Mr Pezzini added: “Organisations not yet engaged with SOA should avoid
attempts at building a long-term business case for SOA. They should
instead justify initial and focused investments in SOA in the context
of projects aimed at addressing business needs with short to mid-term
paybacks. Incremental investments to extend their SOA infrastructure
and to strengthen governance processes should also be cost-justified on
a project-by-project basis in terms of tangible business benefits.”
Additional information is available in the Gartner report "Measuring the Value of SOA". The report is on Gartner's website at http://www.gartner.com/DisplayDocument?ref=g_search&id=833728&subref=simplesearch.
Gartner analysts will present additional insights into SOA at the
Gartner SOA & Application Development and Integration Summit 2009,
24-25 June at the Royal Lancaster hotel in London, UK. The Summit gives
the richest view of SOA, application development, application
integration, multienterprise B2B and emerging trends available.
Additional information is available at www.europe.gartner.com/soa. Members of the media can register by contacting Holly Stevens at holly.stevens@gartner.com.
Contacts:
Holly Stevens
Gartner
+44 0 1784 267412
holly.stevens@gartner.com
Christy Pettey
Gartner
+1 408 468 8312
christy.pettey@gartner.com
About Gartner:
Gartner, Inc. (NYSE: IT) is the world's leading information technology research and advisory company. Gartner delivers the technology-related insight necessary for its clients to make the right decisions, every day. From CIOs and senior IT leaders in corporations and government agencies, to business leaders in high-tech and telecom enterprises and professional services firms, to technology investors, Gartner is the indispensable partner to 60,000 clients in 10,000 distinct organizations. Through the resources of Gartner Research, Gartner Consulting and Gartner Events, Gartner works with every client to research, analyze and interpret the business of IT within the context of their individual role. Founded in 1979, Gartner is headquartered in Stamford, Connecticut, U.S.A., and has 4,000 associates, including 1,200 research analysts and consultants in 80 countries. For more information, visit www.gartner.com.
For more resources on Service-Oriented Architecture check out the: THE SOA NETWORK
Submit Press Releases to THE SOA NETWORK send to SOA@pr2web.com.
Back to Main Page
Gary E. Smith
SOA Enterprise Architect
IT RESOURCE NETWORK
THE CLOUD NETWORK | THE BPM NETWORK | THE SAAS NETWORK | THE SOA NETWORK | WEB 2.0 NETWORK




Comments